A three-minute walk gets you to Turtle Beach from this quiet, character-filled little resort at the island’s very south end. Each of its 10 pet-friendly cottages lines the bay with its own personality, reflected in names such as Rain Forest, Key West and Southwestern. Modern designer furniture and lamps, objets d’art and other decorative pieces carry out the themes. Most of them are two-bedroom, sleeping up to six people. All have a private courtyard with a hot tub.

The property’s small swimming pool has a bay view and a lounge and picnic area with grill. Lush gardens strung with hammocks add to the relaxation factor here. Use of canoes, kayaks, bicycles and fishing gear is complimentary.